Put-in-Bay Food and Drink Pyrates gathering at Hooligans Eating and drinking at Put-in-Bay? Well, here you go! Beer Barrel Saloon Boardwalk Family of Restaurants Boathouse Cameo Pizza Candy Bar Chicken Patio Chocolate Cafe Frosty’s Goat Soup & Whiskey Heineman Winery Hooligans Irish Pub Joe’s Bar Keys Waterfront Mojito Bay Bar Mossback’s Mr. Ed’s Bar & Grille Old Forge Pasquales Put-in-Bay Brewery Reel Bar Roundhouse Bar Sand Bar Tipper’s Topsy Turvey’s Bar & Grill